Managing Risk and Building Trust in a New Business Pitch

Photo by Edge2Edge Media on Unsplash

A new business pitch is a trust-building exercise. Every word, visual, or idea you share either builds trust or adds to the client’s sense of risk. Your job in the pitch isn’t just to demonstrate competence—it’s to tip the balance by lowering the perceived risk while steadily increasing confidence that you’re the agency best equipped to achieve success.

You’ve likely already witnessed this in real time. Maybe it’s the moment during a pitch when the client relaxes and begins to engage. They nod in agreement, ask collaborative rather than combative questions, or start guiding you—coaching, even—toward what success looks like in their minds.

And you’ve probably seen the opposite too. A client goes quiet after the meeting. They stop replying to your emails. You may have “checked the boxes,” but you didn’t capture their imagination—or reduce their fear of making the wrong choice.

Understanding Risk (and Why It’s Personal)

Trust is always personal.

Most theorists agree that trust is a perception about others in relation to oneself. In other words, in a new business pitch situation, your prospective clients take this whole trust-versus-risk thing personally. Here’s what they’re thinking about when they think of the fallout of hiring the wrong agency:

• Professional reputation: If they choose the wrong agency, it’s their name on the line. Especially if the choice was their recommendation.

• Lost opportunity: Selecting the wrong agency doesn’t just waste time—it may mean missing a critical launch, losing market share, or failing to meet KPIs.

• Team disruption: Will this agency gel with their internal team? Or are they going to require hand-holding and extra management oversight?

• Political fallout: Are they displacing a favored incumbent agency or stepping on the toes of a respected colleague?

• Unrecoverable costs: What’s the cost of all the time to train and onboard a new agency that goes to waste?

These are all risk perceptions—some rational, some emotional—and a pitch that ignores them leaves trust to chance. The more you can recognize and address the risks your prospects are carrying, the faster you shift the equation in your favor.

Building Trust in Your Pitch

Building trust and reducing risk is more straightforward than you might think. Here are three basic steps you can take:

1. Clear Communication: Stop Trying to Impress. Start Helping.

Your first and most immediate trust-builder is clarity.

That’s because the part of your prospect’s brain responsible for detecting risk—the amygdala, or “lizard brain”—filters all incoming information and it likes that information to be clear, concise and specific.

Its job is to react quickly to keep us safe from threatening situations. It’s simply not capable of sorting and interpreting cluttered pitch decks, inconsistent messaging, or poorly coordinated team members.

In fact, just the opposite can happen. It raises the spectre of risk in the minds of even the most intelligent of humans no matter how good your ideas are or how overwhelming the evidence that you’re qualified.

I’m probably not the first and likely won’t be the last to offer you this advice, but here goes:

• Lose the jargon. Don’t say you’re “technology-first and platform-agnostic.” Show it, through case studies, stories, and testimonials.

• Put your work in their context. Don’t assume the relevance of your past work is self-evident. Explain how it solves their specific challenges.

• Trim the slide (or page) count. You don’t get extra credit for cramming 90 minutes of content into a 30-minute meeting. It overwhelms your audience—and it triggers their lizard brain.

Prospects don’t need to be dazzled; they want to be heard and understood. And when they feel understood, trust follows.

2. Have a Point of View—Even When It’s Not an Easy One

Expressing a challenging or contrarian opinion—thoughtfully and respectfully—can make you appear more trustworthy, not less.

In most cases, you are selling a specialized solution to a complex problem. And, while the people in the pitch room are accomplished experts in their own right, the complexity of their problems is greater than their ability to solve them.

They need an expert. And experts, by definition, have a perspective informed by experience—successes and failures.

But, in general, agencies like to please. They tell the client what they think the client wants to hear and avoid taking a stand.

Your prospects are looking for guidance. When you say, “Here’s why we recommend a different direction,” you’re signaling leadership, clarity, and confidence. That lowers risk. It also increases trust.

Don’t fear disagreement from the client—fear indifference.

3. Consistency of Narrative: Earn Trust by Being Predictable in the Right Ways

Every touchpoint tells a story about your agency. Your website, your emails, your creds deck, your pitch—it all adds up to a narrative. And your client is paying attention to whether that narrative makes sense.

Unlike a one-off story or anecdote, your narrative is ongoing. It’s open-ended. And it invites participation. Prospects will interpret what you say—and what you don’t—and fill in the blanks.

This is where messaging hygiene becomes essential. If your website says one thing, your deck says another, and your team introduces yet another spin in the room, confusion sets in. Best case: your agency feels muddled. Worst case: you feel untrustworthy.

Assert control over your narrative. Do a regular audit of public touchpoints—website, social media, email outreach copy, decks, bios. Make sure they reflect the same strategic positioning. Align your team to speak with one voice.

Consistency tells your client: “This is who we are, no matter the medium, no matter the moment.” That steadiness is a powerful antidote to perceived risk.

Reframing the Pitch as a Risk-Reduction Process

You don’t win a pitch because you were the most creative or the most affordable. You win because you made it easiest for the client to say yes—by minimizing their sense of risk and maximizing their sense of trust.